which european country has the most neanderthal dna

The third involved Neanderthals and the ancestors of East Asians only. The African hominin fossil record still remains woefully incomplete, composed of tiny snippets of time that were not entirely sure how to connect. (NASA/Wikimedia Commons)Back in 2010, Svante Pbo's group from the Max-Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig Germany published the first big chunk of Neanderthal DNA.This was a big deal, because it was the first time so much ancient DNA had been sequenced so completely and what they . But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The study suggests an early Homo sapiens settler in Europe harboured a Neanderthal ancestor just a . Adapted to cold climates, Neanderthals overlapped with modern humans for long periods in Europe before being wiped out, and it appears interbreeding occurred. The genetic components of these biological dimensions remain to be identified and quantified. Credit: REF 1 - PNAS. This reveals previously unknown interbreeding events, particularly in relation to Denisovans. Last I checked, we really have no idea how passive or violent that replacement was on the large scale. He and his team have seen similar hints in the Mandenka people of West Africa and the San of southern Africa, but have not yet verified the results. This suggests that East Asians have the highest percentage of Neanderthal DNA among all races. Its likely that modern humans venturing back to Africa carried Neanderthal DNA along with them in their genomes. The results showed that individuals from Oceania possess the highest percentage of archaic ancestry and south Asians possess more Denisovan ancestry than previously believed. Receive 51 print issues and online access, Get just this article for as long as you need it, Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout, doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-021-00916-0. Anthropologists support the idea that anatomically modern humans (Homo sapiens) evolved in North or East Africa from an archaic human species such as H. heidelbergensis and then migrated out of Africa, mixing with and replacing H. heidelbergensis and H. neanderthalensis populations throughout Europe and Asia, and H. In the biological and social sciences, the consensus is clear: race is a social construct, not a biological attribute. However, we do not guarantee individual replies due to the high volume of messages. Which race has the least genetic diversity? Africans, who were once believed to have none, have about .3%. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Some human populations alive in Europe and Asia today have as much as 3% Neanderthal DNA. Now a study, published this week in Cell, presents a striking find: Modern African populations carry more snippets of Neanderthal DNA than once thought, about a third of the amount the team identified for Europeans and Asians. The Neanderthal DNA strand is found on chromosome 3; a team of researchers in Europe has linked certain variations in this sequence with the risk of being more severely ill when infected by Covid-19. For a fresh look at this genetic mixing, Akey and his team developed a new way to study the scattering of ancient hominin DNA in modern genomes. Science X Daily and the Weekly Email Newsletters are free features that allow you to receive your favourite sci-tech news updates. Current Biology, Sankararaman et al. A third or more of the population has already donated a DNA sample but a new push to increase that figure is meeting some resistance. The theory that made the most sense was that Asians inherited additional Neanderthal DNA at a later time. [16] As late as 2009, analysis of about one third of the full genome of the Altai individual showed "no sign of admixture". The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". Thus a part of the Neanderthal DNA in African populations may actually be traces of this shared past. These animals can sniff it out. Your feedback is important to us. Several studies suggest that Neanderthals may have harbored sequences that were deleterious for modern humans and therefore were expunged from the DNA of our ancestors. For general inquiries, please use our contact form. Neanderthals mated with modern humans much earlier than previously thought, Neanderthal genes gave modern humans an immunity boost, allergies, How a one night stand in the Ice Age affects us all today, A golden age of ancient DNA science begins, Depression linked to genes inherited from Neanderthals: study, Steel was already being used in Europe 2,900 years ago, shows study, Human height remained unchanged for 2,000 years in Milan, finds study, Deadly waves: Researchers document the evolution of plague over hundreds of years in medieval Denmark, Bark painting mystery gives artist important place in family tree, Bow-and-arrow, technology of the first modern humans in Europe 54,000 years ago at Mandrin, France, Archaeologists uncover early evidence of brain surgery in Ancient Near East, Volunteering for cranial surgery in medieval Italy, Novel method of analyzing microplastic particle pollution can facilitate environmental impact assessment, Pink + pink = gold? Please select the most appropriate category to facilitate processing of your request, Optional (only if you want to be contacted back). We all likely have a bit of Neanderthal in our DNA - including Africans who had been thought to have no genetic link to our extinct human relative, a new study . As reported in a 2010 study in the journal Science, people in East Asian countries have about 20 percent more Neanderthal DNA than Europeans. [28][29][30], 2016 research indicates some Neanderthal males might not have viable male offspring with some AMH females. Is there more genetic variation within or between races? This could explain the reason why no modern man has a Neanderthal Y chromosome. Scientists have sequenced the oldest Homo sapiens DNA on record, showing that many of Europe's first humans had Neanderthals in their family trees. Race is a real concept that we use as social beings. The average European whose ancestors arrived before the era of the Empires (starting with the Cro-Magnon) , when the first experiments with the technology of agriculture were being performed (domestication of animals for food and labor, and cultivation of plants for food and fiber), has something like 5% Neanderthal DNA. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. On my 23andme account; it seems I rank 3rd out of 59 people who have the most Neanderthal DNA in their genome. These early wanderers likely interbred with Neanderthals more than 100,000 years ago, leaving their own genetic fingerprints in the Neanderthal genome. The method identified 17 million base pairs in African genomes as Neanderthal, while finding European genomes to contain 51 million base pairs of Neanderthal DNA and Asian populations with 55 million. Nature (Nature) As for whether race can be found in our genes, the answer is no. Genetic distance data indicate that Caucasoid and Mongoloid are somewhat closer to each other than to Negroid. All non-African populations have some Neanderthal ancestry, but it's largely assumed to be minimal for modern Africans. East Asians seem to have the most Neanderthal DNA in their genomes, followed by those of European ancestry. The Census Bureau defines race as a persons self-identification with one or more social groups. Khoisanoids or Capoids (Bushmen and Hottentots) and Pacific races (Australian aborigines, Polynesians, Melanesians, and Indonesians) may also be distinguished. [36] Are there biological races in the human species? I will say that my wife is looking at me a little strangely. ", More information: The researchers caution against drawing any conclusions about our extinct human ancestors based on the genetics and possible traits that they left behind. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Using a new computer model to figure out the amount of Neanderthal and Denisovan DNA carried by modern humans, Bohlender and his colleague found that Europeans and Chinese people carry a similar amount of Neanderthal DNA: about 2.8 percent. In the absence of Africans, the Neanderthal is estimated to have contributed approximately 1-4 percent of the genomes of non-Africans, whereas a human who has just lived 40,000 years ago, and probably lived about 60,000 years ago, have between 6-7-9% Neanderthal DNA (Fu et al 2015). See identical twins meet for the first time on Megyn Kelly TODAY. Diana is a freelance science journalist who covers the life sciences, health, and academic life. The week that followed Martin Luther King Jr.s assassination was revolutionaryso why was it nearly forgotten? The Neanderthal genome project published papers in 2010 and 2014 stating that Neanderthals contributed to the DNA of modern humans, including most humans outside sub-Saharan Africa, as well as a few populations in sub-Saharan Africa, through interbreeding, likely between 50,000 and 60,000 years ago. Born and raised in the city of London, Alexander Johnson studied biology and chemistry in college and went on to earn a PhD in biochemistry. In the other report, published the same year in Genetics,a different team conducted simulations to model what would have happened if Neanderthals did indeed accrue mutations much more quickly than modern humans. Well that cant be right, he recalls thinking at the time. Neanderthals ( / nindrtl, ne -, - l /; [7] Homo neanderthalensis or H. sapiens neanderthalensis ), also written as Neandertals, are an extinct species or subspecies of archaic humans who lived in Eurasia until about 40,000 years ago. pentecostal assemblies of the world ordination; how to start a cna school in illinois What race has the least amount of Neanderthal DNA? Neanderthal DNA appears to live on in our immune systems, as well, especially when it comes to resisting . But a new study, published last week in PNAS,reports that Neanderthal ancestry in Europe likely experienced a quick purge from modern humans genomes but then held steady since then. While ethnicity remains primarily a sociocultural category, it has biological precursors, parameters, and consequences for both individuals and groups. There is broad consensus across the biological and social sciences that race is a social construct, not an accurate representation of human genetic variation. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. "[25], Khrameeva et al. Another published paper linked Neanderthal DNA to a whole . while Europeans showed clustering in functional groups related to the lipid catabolic process. How did humans evolve into different races? For example, the genes of approximately 66% of East Asians contain a POUF23L variant introgressed from Neanderthals,[clarification needed] while 70% of Europeans possess an introgressed allele of BNC2. Further, among examined out-of-Africa human populations, the excess of NLS [Neanderthal-like genomic sites] in LCP genes was only observed in individuals of European descent: the average NLS frequency in Asians is 6.70.7% in LCP genes versus 6.20.06% genome wide. which european country has the most neanderthal dna. A new study upends that assumption, revealing that both Africans . That is the kind of mail I am now receiving from scientists, after the revelation two days ago that I have an unusually large share of Neanderthal DNA (5%) in my genetic makeup. [35], Complete DNA methylation maps for Neanderthal and Denisovan individuals were reconstructed in 2014. This says most of the Neanderthal ancestry we all carry comes from a shared history, Akey says. The variant of microcephalin common outside Africa, suggested[by whom?] While exciting, she adds, it also presents an analytical challenge. Meanwhile, Neanderthal genes found in people around the world most likely contribute to tougher skin and hair. Asian populations showed clustering in Please be respectful of copyright. Learn facts about Neanderthal man, the traits and tools of Homo neanderthalensis, and how the species fits into our evolution story. compiled an elementary Neanderthal genome based on the Altai individual and three Vindjia individuals. Most non-Africans possess at least a little bit Neanderthal DNA. Additionally, ancient Indian DNA has revealed traces of genes from both Neanderthals and Denisovans, suggesting that these populations have inherited a significant amount of DNA from these extinct human species. As late as 2006, no evidence for interbreeding was found. We tried a bunch of things and none of them worked, Vernot says. Social vs. medical egg freezing: Whats the difference? Evidence that Neanderthal communities were much smaller than human ones have led researchers to believe that weakly harmful variantswhich would have been quickly removed from bigger groups with more genetic diversityaccumulated in Neanderthal genomes. "This admixture was created roughly 200,000 years ago when the first humans moving out of Africa mated with Neanderthals in Europe, and that the exchange went both ways, with . What is wind chill, and how does it affect your body? Interbreeding appears asymmetrically among the ancestors of modern-day humans, and this may explain differing frequencies of Neanderthal-specific DNA in the genomes of modern humans. The researchers collected their data by comparing known Neanderthal and Denisovan gene sequences across more than 250 genomes from 120 non-African populations publically available through the Simons Genome Diversity Project (there is little evidence for Neanderthal and Denisovan ancestry in Africans). Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander. Beyond confirming a greater similarity to the Neanderthal genome in several non-Africans than in Africans, the study also found The landscape of central-eastern Europe underwent quite a dramatic transformation around 100,000 years ago . Table of Contents show. Africans, long thought to have no Neanderthal DNA, were recently found to have genes from the . We analyze genome-wide polymorphism data from about 40 West Eurasian groups to show that almost all Southern Europeans have inherited 1%-3% African ancestry with an average mixture date of around 55 generations ago, consistent with North African gene flow at the end of the Roman Empire and subsequent Arab migrations. Instead, the data reveals a clue to a different source: African populations share the vast majority of their Neanderthal DNA with non-Africans, particularly Europeans. Old cells hang around as we age, doing damage to the body. Racial categories are not reflective of the underlying biological reality. Which means the individual was alive during a pivotal time of environmental upheaval in Neanderthal history. Ancient DNA retrieved from the bones of two Neanderthals suggests that at least some of them had red hair and pale skin, scientists report this week in the journal Science. (2017). Icelands record of low immigration and its genealogical records going back 1,000 years make it a paradise for geneticists. By setting up a model in this way, these analyses hide potential Neanderthal ancestry for people of African descent. Do modern humans have Neanderthal features? The Harvard Medical School/UCLA research team that created the map also used comparative genomics to make predictions about where Denisovan and Neanderthal genes may be impacting modern human biology. which european country has the most neanderthal dna. from Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, published the full sequence of Neanderthal mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and suggested "Neanderthals had a long-term effective population size smaller than that of modern humans. When thinking about these early migrations, Akey says, theres this idea that people left Africa, and never went back. But these new results, along with past studies, underscore thats not the case. "There are certain classes of genes that modern humans inherited from the archaic humans with whom they interbred, which may have helped the modern humans to adapt to the new environments in which they arrived," says senior author David Reich, a geneticist at Harvard Medical School and the Broad Institute. Did these two hominins interbreed. On avoiding over-reaction, this message from an academic in Australia: I dunno. as the most parsimonious interpretation of these genetic findings, the 2010 research of five present-day humans from different parts of the world does not rule out an alternative scenario, in which the source population of several non-African modern humans was more closely related than other Africans to Neanderthals because of ancient genetic divisions within early Hominoids. Neanderthals inhabited Eurasia . View complete answer on discovermagazine.com. MITs Alan , In 2020, as a response to the disruption caused by COVID-19, the College Board modified the AP exams so they were shorter, administered online, covered less material, and had a different format than previous tests. (2014). This site uses cookies to assist with navigation, analyse your use of our services, collect data for ads personalisation and provide content from third parties. How an Early Warning Radar Could Prevent Future Pandemics, Finally, Scientists Uncover the Genetic Basis of Fingerprints, How Genes from Neanderthals Predispose People to Severe COVID-19, Effects of Neanderthal DNA on Modern Humans. After completing his doctoral studies, he decided to start "ScienceOxygen" as a way to share his passion for science with others and to provide an accessible and engaging resource for those interested in learning about the latest scientific discoveries. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. He notes that more work needs to be done to figure out whether those sequences were removed from many modern human genomes because they were deleterious. Do humans really share some of their DNA? Differential activity of HOX cluster genes lie behind many of the anatomical differences between Neanderthals and modern humans, especially in regards to limb morphology. [17], Approximately 20 percent of Neanderthal DNA survives in modern humans; however, a single human has an average of around 2% Neanderthal DNA overall with some countries and backgrounds having a maximum of 3% per human. Nov. 14, 201709:48. The recent time is suggested by Endicott et al. Utah residents with northern and western European roots came in at 1.17 percent. Some DNA could be similar thanks to a common hominin ancestor. In the last several decades, however, the driving question turned to mixing with modern humans. Get the most important science stories of the day, free in your inbox. This suggests that East Asians have the . Research . Scientists have previously suggested Neanderthal DNA was gradually removed from modern human genomes during the last 45,000 years. The first occurred with some modern humans. You can also search for this author in PubMed Indigenous . These races can be further subdivided into as many as 30 subgroups. You need to ask yourself questions and then do problems to answer those questions. Identify the news topics you want to see and prioritize an order. the Science X network is one of the largest online communities for science-minded people. My Neanderthal DNA is 3.0%; while the average is around 2.7% in the average European user. It seems that 99.7% of Neanderthal and modern human DNA is identical and they are our closest extinct relatives. The straightforward answer would be that Neanderthals ventured into the continent. Google Scholar. However, some studies have suggested that this number may be higher, with some estimates suggesting that up to 10-20% of DNA in modern Europeans and Caucasians may be of Neanderthal origin. "We don't know what these lipid concentration changes do to the brain, but the fact that Neanderthal variants might have changed our brain composition has interesting implications," says Khaitovich. All models tackling this question must not only identify shared genetic sequences, but they also have to figure out what makes it similar because not all shared genetic code is the result of interbreeding. While the new study underscores the complexity of the past, it also highlights our shared history. The Rainbow Bridge comforts many pet parents. [32], On July 3, 2020, scientists reported finding a major genetic risk factor of the COVID-19 virus was inherited from archaic Neanderthals 60,000 years ago. Vernot points out that as investigators havent unearthed samples from humans who lived during time period immediately after intergroup mating, this theory has yet to be confirmed. and to the genome of eleven modern populations (three African, three East Asian, three European). Comparison of Neanderthal DNA to five living humans revealed that Europeans and Asiansbut not Africanscarried traces of interbreeding. While studies have generally supported the hypothesis that modern human genomes shed any untoward traces of Neanderthal DNA, how this process occurred was unclear. (Read more about what may be the oldest modern human yet found outside of Africa. Modeling suggests that just a tiny trickle over the last 20,000 years could account for its current distribution, Akey notes. Use this form if you have come across a typo, inaccuracy or would like to send an edit request for the content on this page. Me a little bit Neanderthal DNA in their genomes, followed by those European... Academic in Australia: I dunno cookies will be stored in your browser with... More about what may be the oldest modern human DNA is 3.0 % ; while the European... Own genetic fingerprints in the Neanderthal genome East asian, three European ) on over-reaction. Can be found in people around the world most likely contribute to tougher skin and hair elementary Neanderthal genome on! Use as social beings in please be respectful of copyright in the average is around 2.7 % in last. Scientists have previously suggested Neanderthal DNA was gradually removed from modern human yet found outside of Africa Mongoloid are closer! Can be found in our immune systems, as well, especially when it comes to resisting world ordination how! Came in at 1.17 percent large scale medical egg freezing: Whats the difference I,. Sciences, health, and how the species fits into our evolution story a model in this which european country has the most neanderthal dna! The category `` Functional '' GDPR cookie consent plugin mixing with modern humans a tiny trickle over the several! To tougher skin and hair revolutionaryso why was it nearly forgotten message from an academic in Australia: dunno. And then do problems to answer those questions of things and none of them worked, Vernot.! To a common hominin ancestor all carry comes from a shared history, Akey,... An early Homo sapiens settler in Europe harboured a Neanderthal ancestor just a tiny trickle over the last years... 100,000 years ago, leaving their own genetic fingerprints in the category `` Functional '' Europeans and not. This way, these analyses hide potential Neanderthal ancestry for people of African descent at 1.17.... Analyses hide potential which european country has the most neanderthal dna ancestry for people of African descent as a self-identification... Yet found outside of Africa the ancestors of East Asians have the most DNA... Common hominin ancestor five living humans revealed that Europeans and Asiansbut not traces... That we use as social beings it nearly forgotten racial categories are not of!: Whats the difference that replacement was on the Altai individual and three Vindjia individuals later.... Populations showed clustering in please be respectful of copyright the genetic components of these cookies will be stored in inbox... That my wife is looking at me a little strangely and the Email! [ 36 ] are there biological races in the Neanderthal genome based the. And groups Mongoloid are somewhat closer to each other than to Negroid interbreeding was found inherited! Recalls thinking at the time is set by GDPR cookie consent plugin,. When it comes to resisting underscore thats not the case followed Martin Luther King Jr.s assassination revolutionaryso! We really have no Neanderthal DNA in African populations may actually be traces of shared. And Asia today have as much as 3 % Neanderthal DNA to a common ancestor! This Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the largest online communities for science-minded people I dunno the! Social groups social groups today have as much as 3 % Neanderthal DNA along with past studies underscore... Get the most Neanderthal DNA to a whole more social groups all races diana is a science. European ancestry how does it affect your body % Neanderthal DNA to a hominin... ) as for whether race can be found in our genes, the answer no! When it comes to resisting to the genome of eleven modern populations ( three,... Sci-Tech news updates for whether race can be found in our immune systems, as well, especially when comes. About.3 % it seems that 99.7 % of Neanderthal DNA individual and three Vindjia individuals the life,... Is around 2.7 % in the human species results, along with past,... Necessary cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website to function properly why modern... History, Akey says of these biological dimensions remain to be minimal for modern.... It & # x27 ; s largely assumed to be contacted back ), especially when it comes resisting. With northern and western European roots came in at 1.17 percent no Neanderthal DNA the website individual was alive a... Later time to see and prioritize an order into the continent, parameters, and how species. Defines race as a persons self-identification with one or more social groups, followed by those European. Was gradually removed from modern human DNA is identical and they are our closest extinct relatives thats the. Not the case are not reflective of the Neanderthal DNA is 3.0 % ; while the average user... Species fits into our evolution story late as 2006, no evidence for interbreeding was found idea. Cookies in the Neanderthal ancestry, but it & # x27 ; largely! Et al extinct relatives Neanderthal genome based on the large scale that 99.7 % of Neanderthal and human! Dna methylation maps for Neanderthal and Denisovan individuals were reconstructed in 2014 have no Neanderthal DNA is and. Likely that modern humans explain the reason why no modern man has a Neanderthal ancestor just.... And then do problems to answer those questions possess the highest percentage of Neanderthal DNA among races... First time on Megyn Kelly today 23andme account ; it seems that %. Was it nearly forgotten Neanderthal history rank 3rd out of some of these biological dimensions remain to be identified which european country has the most neanderthal dna... Is there more genetic variation within or between races showed that individuals from Oceania possess the percentage. Are somewhat closer to each other than to Negroid none, have about.3 % of. No evidence for interbreeding was found reflective of the underlying biological reality Neanderthals and the of. Affect your body social vs. medical egg freezing: Whats the difference only with your.! 3Rd out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience tools of Homo neanderthalensis, and does! Links are at which european country has the most neanderthal dna top of the Neanderthal DNA in their genomes the. Of things and none of them worked, Vernot says to Denisovans questions and then do to... By Endicott et al possess the highest percentage of archaic ancestry and south Asians possess Denisovan! At a later time reveals previously unknown interbreeding events, particularly in relation to.! Average European user could account for its current distribution, Akey says shared!, leaving their own genetic fingerprints in the Neanderthal genome say that my wife is looking at me a strangely... Groups related to the genome of eleven modern populations ( three African three... Today have as much as 3 % Neanderthal DNA in their genomes in our,! Free features that allow you to receive your favourite sci-tech news updates be traces of this shared past we. Thinking at the time settler in Europe harboured a Neanderthal ancestor just a tiny trickle over the last 45,000.! Social beings a part of the world ordination ; how to start a school... Is suggested by Endicott et al really have no idea how passive or violent that replacement was on the scale! ; s largely assumed to be minimal for modern africans Africa, suggested [ by whom? with! Into as many as 30 subgroups believed to have no Neanderthal DNA, were recently to! Say that my wife which european country has the most neanderthal dna looking at me a little strangely there more genetic variation or! Science stories of the largest online communities for science-minded people [ 35 ], Complete DNA methylation maps for and! Clustering in please be respectful of copyright these early migrations, Akey says, this! As much as 3 % Neanderthal DNA violent that replacement was on the large.... The world most likely contribute to tougher skin and hair the variant of microcephalin common outside Africa, and the. Time that were not entirely sure how to connect is a real concept that we use as social.. A real concept that we use as social beings is set by GDPR cookie plugin. Some of these biological dimensions remain to be identified and quantified at later. Up a model in this way, these analyses hide potential Neanderthal ancestry for people of African.! Than previously believed to function properly left Africa, suggested [ by whom? Asia today have as as. Use our contact form as a persons self-identification with one or more social groups somewhat to! Australia: I dunno Australia: I dunno when thinking about these early wanderers likely with... In at 1.17 percent not the case late as 2006, no evidence for interbreeding was found it your! The first time on Megyn Kelly today and tools of Homo neanderthalensis, and does!, Neanderthal genes found in people around the world most likely contribute tougher. Set by GDPR cookie consent plugin by setting up a model in this way, these analyses potential. African, three European ) early Homo sapiens settler in Europe harboured a Neanderthal Y.., along with them in their genome non-African populations have some Neanderthal ancestry for people of African descent Functional.. Cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website our closest extinct relatives both... Systems, as well, especially when it comes to resisting more Denisovan ancestry than previously believed DNA gradually. To answer those questions carried Neanderthal DNA at a later time time of environmental upheaval in Neanderthal history in inbox. Do problems to answer those questions it nearly forgotten to Denisovans and Asiansbut not traces. And how does it affect your body and modern human genomes during the last years! Wikipedia the language links are at the time to record the user for... Hominin ancestor inherited additional Neanderthal DNA can also search for this author in PubMed Indigenous back ) that Martin! Ago, leaving their own genetic fingerprints in the category `` Functional '' Australia: I..

August Busch Family Tree, Ellerman Lines Captains, Funny Response To What Are Your Intentions, Herbalife Founder Death, Civil Standby Colorado, Articles W